Bat Speed -- Baseball Hitting Forum

Posted by: () on Tue Jun 18 13:33:44 2002

Hi -- I hope the clarification below is require by only a few.
> >
> > “The batter has rotated to the launch position and completed his timing step. The front foot has been firmly planted. Forward motion has flow to a stop and he is ready to initiate the swing. Now, it is as if a stake had been driven down through the head and body, out the butt and into 6 feet of concrete; this will be the axis the batter will rotate on.”
> >
> > The paragraph above is from a featured article on the site, “Rotation and the Stationary Axis.” The stationary axis is a key component to rotational mechanic and I have discussed it at length many times. – I assumed that anyone with normal intelligence would understand that the head would remain fairly stationary during the swing (“a stake had been driven down through the head”). But for those that need more of the dots filled in to see the picture, I guess that I should also point out that the forward movement of the eyes, nose, forehead and ears has also stopped.
> >
> > Jack Mankin
> >
>
> I'll bet anyone who has had a golf lesson has been told to keep the head still.This is common advice for beginners,but becomes constraining as the golfer develops.Another piece of advice for golfers as they progress is to pretend that the head is in the corner of a room at ceiling height such that it can't go forward(toward target) or out or up.Back and down some,however, is usually OK.In hitting it is probably also OK to go up a little with some necessary posture adjustments for a given pitch.

The fact is that all the movements discussed can be done AND THE HITTER CAN MOVE HIS HEAD. In the frame-by-frame describes the postion of the feet, knees, hips, chest, shoulders, arms, hands and elbows. But not the head. The head is not even mentioned. Its not mentioned in the article Jack quotes. The reader is to conclude that the head does not move.

Is this good coaching or teaching? One of the most important aspects of the swing is left for people to from all the other things that are said.

Since, during the swing, the entire body is moving it is more likly that the head will move then that it won't move. Why wouldn't a student assume that, since its more likly to happen and no one said NOT to do it, then its ok to do?

Followups:

Re: Re: Re: Head Movement ?? Jack Mankin [ Tue Jun 18 15:02:53 2002 ]

Post a followup:

Name:

E-mail:

Subject:

Text:

> Hi -- I hope the clarification below is require by only a few.
> > > 
> > > “The batter has rotated to the launch position and completed his timing step. The front foot has been firmly planted. Forward motion has flow to a stop and he is ready to initiate the swing. Now, it is as if a stake had been driven down through the head and body, out the butt and into 6 feet of concrete; this will be the axis the batter will rotate on.”
> > > 
> > > The paragraph above is from a featured article on the site, “Rotation and the Stationary Axis.” The stationary axis is a key component to rotational mechanic and I have discussed it at length many times. – I assumed that anyone with normal intelligence would understand that the head would remain fairly stationary during the swing (“a stake had been driven down through the head”).  But for those that need more of the dots filled in to see the picture, I guess that I should also point out that the forward movement of the eyes, nose, forehead and ears has also stopped.
> > > 
> > > Jack Mankin 
> > > 
> > 
> > I'll bet anyone who has had a golf lesson has been told to keep the head still.This is common advice for beginners,but becomes constraining as the golfer develops.Another piece of advice for golfers as they progress is to pretend that the head is in the corner of a room at ceiling height such that it can't go forward(toward target) or out or up.Back and down some,however, is usually OK.In hitting it is probably also OK to go up a little with some necessary posture adjustments for a given pitch.
> 
> The fact is that all the movements discussed can be done AND THE HITTER CAN MOVE HIS HEAD. In the frame-by-frame describes the postion of the feet, knees, hips, chest, shoulders, arms, hands and elbows. But not the head. The head is not even mentioned. Its not mentioned in the article Jack quotes.  The reader is to conclude that the head does not move.
> 
> Is this good coaching or teaching?  One of the most important aspects of the swing is left for people to from all the other things that are said. 
> 
> Since, during the swing, the entire body is moving it is more likly that the head will move then that it won't move. Why wouldn't a student assume that, since its more  likly to happen and no one said NOT to do it, then its ok to do?

Anti-Spambot Question:

This MLB Stadium is in Boston?
   Yankees park
   Three Rivers
   Safeco Park
   Fenway Park