Re: Which Mechanic is Quicker to the Ball?

Posted by: Jack Mankin (MrBatspeed@aol.com) on Sat Jul 30 21:47:36 2005

>>> I think many select and high coaches believe that a linear hitting approach allows the hitter to be "quicker to the ball", and that rotational hitting results in a longer swing, which requires the hitter to initiate their swing sooner, thus they are more likely to get fooled by an offspeed pitch.

I have been following this board for over a year and I am just a parent that is intrigued by the rotational hitting approach but doesn't know enough about hitting to refute the claims made by proponents of linear hitting. I would appreciate any feedback or comments on this subject. Thanks <<<

Hi Jordan

I agree that many (if not most) high school and college coaches (baseball and softball) teach a form of linear mechanics similar to those demonstrated in this clip - http://webpages.charter.net/nickkio/HandstoBall/Linear05.mpg . I also agree these coaches think this straighter (A to B) hand-path demonstrated results in a quicker and shorter swing.

However, as Andy points out in his post below, it is a myth. I have charted many of these swings and found that the straighter a batter ‘s mechanics extends the hands, the longer the swing and the longer it takes to bring the bat-head to contact. Andy used Sammy Sosa as an example of a rotational swing. See clip http://www.youthbaseballcoaching.com/mpg/sosa_sammy3.mpeg

Sammy has not committed to the swing until he fully initiates it – hands start forward, shoulders start to rotate – about frame 14. At frame 18 he makes contact. 4 video frames (4/30 second) = .13 sec. The more linear swings I have charted (Pros included) took 5 to 6 frames. --- Now start at frame 14 and see if Sammy has a long swing to contact. Note that at contact, his back-elbow is still in the “L” position at his side. The back-arm is nearing full extension with linear mechanics – 8 to 10 inches farther out to contact.

I often ask linear coaches – “As the hands are extending out farther and farther toward contact, is the swing getting quicker and shorter?

Jack Mankin

Followups:
 Re: Re: Which Mechanic is Quicker to the Ball? Shawn [ Mon Aug 1 17:54:59 2005 ] Palmiero ray porco [ Tue Aug 2 18:27:02 2005 ] WINSTROL BABY ray porco [ Wed Aug 3 17:43:30 2005 ] Re: Re: Re: Which Mechanic is Quicker to the Ball? grc [ Mon Aug 1 18:50:56 2005 ] Re: Re: Re: Re: Which Mechanic is Quicker to the Ball? Shawn [ Mon Aug 1 20:21:53 2005 ] Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Which Mechanic is Quicker to the Ball? Jack Mankin [ Tue Aug 2 01:12:45 2005 ] Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Which Mechanic is Quicker to the Ball? Shawn [ Tue Aug 2 11:32:23 2005 ] Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Which Mechanic is Quicker to the Ball? Shawn [ Tue Aug 2 11:25:46 2005 ] Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Which Mechanic is Quicker to the Ball? Jack Mankin [ Tue Aug 2 16:53:32 2005 ] Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Which Mechanic is Quicker to the Ball? Shawn [ Wed Aug 3 13:40:46 2005 ] Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Which Mechanic is Quicker to the Ball? Jack Mankin [ Wed Aug 3 14:26:55 2005 ] Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Which Mechanic is Quicker to the Ball? ray porco [ Wed Aug 3 17:13:49 2005 ] Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Which Mechanic is Quicker to the Ball? ray porco [ Tue Aug 2 03:14:34 2005 ]

Post a followup:
Name:
E-mail:
Subject:
Text:

Anti-Spambot Question:
 Who hit a record 70 home runs in one season?    Kobe Bryant    Wayne Gretzky    Walter Payton    Barry Bonds

[   SiteMap   ]